Saturday, April 22, 2023

A Thousand Splendid Suns- Psychoanalytic research essay

 Mariam and Laila, the two lead protagonists of Khaled Hosseini’s A Thousand Splendid Suns display the Fruedian psychoanalytic theory of Transference and Resistance when acting upon their decisive processes of Laila’s hope and perseverance in contrast to Mariam's sacrifice and noble humility. In Psychoanalysis, we treat troubling mental conditions by investigating the interaction of both conscious and unconscious elements of the mind while simultaneously surfacing repressed fears and intrusive thoughts with various therapy methods, such as dream analysis and Transference therapy. The two women in abusive circumstances have used psychoanalysis as a resource for making sense of the social upheavals of the century, especially those involving gender relations, sexuality, and family life. 


According to the Debatable Austrian Psychoanalyst Sigmund Freud and his mentor Josef Breuer, the term transference is a term referring to unknowingly transferring feelings about someone or something from their past onto their empathically attuned therapist to test their client's perception of reality, While Counter-transference, on the other hand, is the therapist’s reaction and line of treatment to the projections of the client. Over the years, this method has gone under scrutiny for its ethics and mere violation of professional boundaries. But despite this, Transference can be seen in countless social-relational situations and exchanges. If we like Mariam, were raised in an unaccepting and emotionally neglectful environment our reaction to love could result in an initial reaction of shock and disbelief but in some cases will evolve to acceptance and the protection of such a relationship (Mariam and Aziza). The mundane act of an infant curling their fingers around your finger is an act of transference because the reaction of this would exponentially explain how we react to someone “wanting” us. 


Sequentially, Psychoanalysis is closely surrounded by the learning theory of Social constructivism, that knowledge is all socially situated and purely garnered from our interactions with others. In review, the rigid difference between Mariam and Laila’s upbringings merely defines their response to abuse. Yet, while Laila learns from Mariam to be tolerant and submissive for the sake of survival, Mariam learns from Laila what true love and friendship look like. This is the factor that sets Laila free and Mariam to her fateful grave. In that argument from the pro-constructionist position, understanding is not automatically driven by the forces of nature, but instead the result of an active, cooperative enterprise of persons in a relationship. Neurobiologically, victims of abusive conditioning learn that survival is a need that tops emotional needs and love according to Maslow,s model of the Hierarchy of needs. If becoming silent and submissive keeps you from beatings or any negative consequences your abuser may inflict, you will achieve that conformity for the sake of survival, even if it damages your psyche in the long term. The priority after Rasheed’s business burns down is survival or primal motivations. 

In this light, Rasheed's aversion towards Aziza unmasks in one, his preference towards his son, but his misogyny and belief that she is not biologically his. When it’s revealed Rasheed lied about Tariq’s death, it is underlined that Laila only stayed with Rasheed because she falsely thought she had nowhere else to go. Mariam only stayed with Rasheed because she really had no choice. “Recent research on IPA indicates that women remain chained to the dangerously controlled and maintained relationship despite its social and psychological repercussions. Exitance of Intimate Partner Abuse has been seen through the lens of criminal activity. Therefore, the perpetuation of IPA is linked to the psychotic and criminal intentions of the perpetrator” (According to  Shaheed Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto of the Institute of Science and Technology) Once these fundamental reasons set the characters to the point they are in, their rationale and cognitive balances can be dissected further. More significantly, Rasheed may subconsciously feel intimidated and jealous of Azizaś's real father; Tariq. As a matter of fact, After Mariam faithfully turns herself into the Taliban after the ¨Murder¨ of Rasheed, Mariam realizes she has a complete life. In narration “and yet she was leaving the world as a woman who had love and been loved back. she was leaving it as a friend, a companion, a guardian. a mother. a person of consequence at last.” (chapter 47, pg. 370) She realizes her worth despite it all. This should be described as the theory of Eros, the life instinct and the forces of the ego of the organized, logic-driven part of a person’s psyche that mediates desires and love. She could have irrationally joined Laila on her escape, but the power of the Eros led her to decide otherwise. This power of thinking is demonstrated in people that have healthy attachment styles and have been raised in relatively positive environments growing up in both pre-cognitive stages (as infants and young children) all the way to the age of abstract and hypothetical thinking. Though logically rational, Mariam’s line of thinking reveals she does not consider herself to be worthy enough over Rasheed’s life. She still owes the debt of taking another one’s life. 


Alternatively, After Mariam faithfully turns herself in for the “murder” of Rasheed, Mariam experiences a vid and thoughtful review of her life. “Mariam had disjointed dreams that last night. She dreamed of pebbles, eleven of them, arranged vertically. Jalil, young again, all winning smiles and dimpled chins and sweat patches, coat flung over his shoulder, come at last to take his daughter away in his shiny black Buick Roadmaster. Mullah Fazullah twirled his rosary beads, walking with her along the stream, their twin shadows gliding on the water and on the grassy banks sprinkled with a blue lavender wild iris that, in this dream smelled like cloves. She dreamed of Nana in the doorway of the kolba, her voice is dim and distant, calling her to dinner as Mariam played in the cool tangled grass.” (Hosseini, pg. 223) In a review of this dream, Mariam is visiting a time in her life when she felt contempt, but altering the roles of her parents to be modified to her liking. Her father Jalil is closer and more attentive and her mother is farther from tainting Mariam’s heart with disappointing truths. All along Mariam suffered the consequences of another’s grief. Nana took out her disdain and sense of pain caused by the rejection she faced in her life for her having an illegitimate child with her employer. Then Jalil took out his grief on losing his child and his ex-wife on Mariam, especially after she could not naturally conceive another son for him. 


In Summary, with Psychoanalysis and its pragmatic theory of human thought and contemplation, Mariam and Laila’s friendship serve to explain the difference between their behavioral thought and cognition. From Mariam’s sacrifice and Laila’s escape. The unfair disadvantages the two characters had over each other can make up for the reason, they both had the fate the other one did not. Despite it all, they cared for each other, and all behaviors and intrinsic motivations led to their leaving Rasheed but in two different directions. 


Sources:

"Shaheed Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Institute of Science and Technology Researchers Report Research in Sustainable Business and Society (Critical Discourse Analysis of Trauma Bonding in Female Victims of Intimate Partner Abuse: A Phenomenological ...)." Women's Health Weekly, 16 Mar. 2023, p. 6156. Gale General OneFile Custom, link.gale.com/apps/doc/A740884220/GPS?u=j015901&sid=bookmark-GPS&xid=f2ed7034. Accessed 18 Apr. 2023.

Mead HK, Beauchaine TP, Shannon KE. Neurobiological adaptations to violence across development. Dev Psychopathol. 2010 Winter;22(1):1-22. doi: 10.1017/S0954579409990228. PMID: 20102643; PMCID: PMC2813461. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2813461/A 

Monday, April 10, 2023

untitled poem inspired by Sylvia Plath

 The following poem is inspired by the engaging confessional poetry of Sylvia Plath. She participated in the growing spread of Surrealism as a philosophy and form of art.  Although Plath was a pioneer beyond her living time, she suffered from clinical depression. In 1956 she married the English poet Ted Hughes; they had two children together. The couple separated in 1962. In 1963, Slvia passed away from suicide by the gas oven in the Home, the children were physically unharmed but the devastation still plagued the family for decades later. As writers, I believe it’s more than important to understand and honor the eminent power of those before us, that Inspire us now. 



It is before me, the silky marbelized inking,

Moving like a stone among a waterfall; drips

Its word travels through the air, a scorched syllable


It is quiet, but still a harmony it is singing,

Liked the tongue of a stranger inside bruised lips,

So quaint it must be invisible


It is devolving now, stars that are shrinking,

Dismembering at the sight of its own reflection; fits

Its form is so potent now, inhaled volatilizable


It is behind me, but still, it is seething,

Like unstained by the earth, milky bones, honestly: it sits

So particular that way, it is non-refillable


It is motionless now, wet from the sea, still wringing

Splashing at the sight of its own depiction; resists

Its existence is so futile now, so frail it is not even fixable


Wednesday, March 22, 2023

"Ephebic Cries"

 Then existed a boy, threaded together by a dead mother's love, and empty door frames. The fearlessness was a shield, Imaginary. Then a boy existed, who wore baggy jeans and a heaping amount of Citré Shine Hair Gel over his frosted tips. Then he was 18 years old, he talked back, violated speed limits, and ran laps alone, down the block, late after sundown. He lived in a home of Instability, but he peeled his socks off in bed, his room rooted in heat, hungover he slept in. He was fevered and knotted with fresh business by the hours. Now? I’m 48 years old and I’m not married. I don’t run anymore, not with my back too sore and my ankles swollen. My stability? I’m glued down strong. Now, it is a lonely place. Now, I wring my hands at an office cubicle, with razor nicks eating my neck. But when I doze off, I witness the hot hands around his back, kissing her lips of a blurred complexion. The crowd and the thumping of a Stereo, it was a fog so dampened by ephebic life. My memory serves me visions. A relationship gone too soon. It was a girl, so penetrating, piercing, He drank her shadow, his fingers combing her hair and around her hands around my back as we mouthed each other’s sultry fantasies. Glitter pasted to the sticky floors. Our skin is still pink with infancy. I don’t remember her name, don’t know if she had one. Could it have been the tickles of a changing body? The persuasion from a passion fruit wine too old for his own good. Drink the kool-aid and be free. Close the door and keep it locked. We’ll be one forever until we’re thousands of pieces apart. We can trust each other until we can’t. I don’t trust anymore, but I pay my prices. I keep the TV on at all hours to conceal the silence, not the silence, the absence of noise. That commotion I used to know, those conversations I once eavesdropped. High school was complete with the girl that dipped her head out a car window, professed secrets onto hallway walls, and hollowed her eyes with dark liner. Now, romances come and go. Commitment, I cannot afford. Even when I did, I never bought it. He Imagined he felt nothing when he saw her run around with other boys. How he pretended violence was boring, like he knew real conflict. Now, my eyes go dry at murder. Real news does not approach enough to even nauseate me. If his feet were too slow, He’d drive a little faster. He’d master the danger. He was not afraid. Now, there’s no thrill that fondles risk. There’s no playful in rationality. He figured his soul was so charred, if he peeled back the dead remains, they would reveal a version of himself too precious to expose to the infective world around him. His gullibility is so adorable. His despondency was so sweet, but so beaten, it grew black. Now, there’s no exploitation I have to fear. Now exists a man, a spiritless number so bleak and obsolete. Momentarily then and again, I’ll open a drawer. I find journal entries, report cards, and yellowing polaroid's. Now exists a false freedom. Then existed a boy, sobbing burgeoning tears, but every moment, he bled liberation.


Sunday, December 11, 2022

mary ann cotton} the black widow killer

 Mary Ann Cotton; The First British Serial Killer 


“Lord Jesus receive my spirit, Oh Lord have mercy upon me” said Mary Ann Cotton moments before prison executioner Robert Anderson released his grip on the rope that left Cotton defeated, and dangling on the noose. March 24th, 1873 when the “Black Widow Killer” had been charged the death sentanc for murdering her seven-year old stepson, Charles Edward Cotton with a fatal dose of arsenic. 


It is undeniable that Mary Ann Cotton was a wretched and sickeningly wrong woman for what she’s accused of, but It should be known as well much of her story is not known. Between the years of 1865 and 1872 it is publicly believed to be the time period she committed her murders: 21 victims. Mary had 13 children of her own, but only two of those children survived to meet their adulthood. Margeret Edith, her youngest daughter she gave birth to during her trial and her son George Cotton, from a separate marriage where she lost custody of the child, are amongst the only “happy endings” of the long strand of Mary’s wrath of calamity. All 11 other Children died from illness, illnesses she concealed by “the arsenic in the wallpaper” disguise. Along with them, were the 4 husbands (William Mowbray, George Ward, James Robinson and Frederick Cotton) 2 of her lovers (who remain unidentified) and the rest, chalked up to victims of the 1858 Bradford Poisoning Incident. 

Apart from an average early 19th century upbringing, Mary Ann suffered a difficult childhood, Her parents identified in the working class and were relatively frugal as she grew up, Her mom often was too ill to work and her father was a miner. She grew to hate them, especially her father who was incredibly strict and dominating towards her and her brother. Mary Ann was limited from church events and evening parties and because of these conditions, she never made many friends; Therefore, causing Mary Ann to become isolated with her resentment.. In 1848, when Mary Ann was only eleven, her father Michael Robson died from a workplace mining accident. His body was quite literally brought home on a wheelbarrow, in a sack marked “Property of the South Hetton Coal Company''.  It is said by many sources, Cotton was a very private woman and something as personal as mournfulness and depression, would not be mentioned by even the people most close to her. Her mix between grief and anger may have confused the young woman, creating a cocktail of spite and overall very negative perceptions of Human Nature and sense of Morality. At only 14, Mary Ann dropped out of school to practice nursing. Mary Ann’s first taste of independence was her job as a “Culinary Manager '' at South Hetton, her only shot at adulthood was chores, cleaning, and nursing children. Because Mary Ann was denied her dreams to escape the Mining District, she was urged into a low-income, low-status job, causing her to hate Children and the knowledge they lacked, to understand the sacrifices made by adults. Mary Ann retired home three years later to pursue a career in dress making and at 19-20 years old married a Colliery laborer William Nowbray, before soon becoming pregnant with their first child. 


Additionally, what may have been secretly damaging to Mary Ann was growing up in such a deeply strict household, a Methodist atmosphere. Her father was extremely strict and soon after his death, Mary Ann witnessed her mother grow tired of the financial abandonment. When Mary Ann’s mother, Margeret’s new husband moved into the house-Mary Ann left. Maybe there was something disgraceful in the mind of Mary Ann about the overwhelming structure of a family life and starting a family of her own, would be just as miserable. During Mary-Ann’s first marriage the young couple fled almost as far away as north-east they could go without leaving England. Before Mary Ann was even 24 years old, she already had 4 children. We only know about these children because of a death certificate, discovered for Margaret Jane Mowbray, born in June of 1855 in a local St.Germans Hospital. But the previous children are shrouded in mystery. Little Margaret Jane died, and the death certificate would actually disprove any position, It was in reality, labeled as Scarlatina (Scarlet Fever), fairly common among the Mining communities, that Mary Ann actually took considerable measures to avoid. Colliery doctor Samuel Broadbent, who made the diagnosis, could have easily mistaken the symptoms of Scarlet fever for Arsenic poisoning, but any evidence is slim to none, except for the red rash on the young child’s body which is unique to that illness, a bacterial fungal infection. 


Even during the process of analyzing Margerret Jane’s death, Mary Ann was already conceiving again, now they’ve already produced 8 children (ranked in age under 8 years old) - Isabella, Margaret Jane (another Margaret Jane), Robert, William, John and a Newborn, Elizabeth. But soon one of them-Baby John was dead at just a year old, as having died from Diarrhea (a common symptom of Arsenic poisoning). The death of three children in such rapid succession and all in one household but Victorian Medicine did as good as nothing to treat typhoid and cholera, same as Scarlatina and Smallpox, which was assumed to be the cause of demise for most of the children. In Consideration, Victorian England was the place of poverty was endemic, birth control was misunderstood and Abortion illegal, many Women, Unfortunately resorted to infanticide. Apparently, children being murdered by their own mother, was far from uncommon. In 1849 a Wiltshire Woman called Rebecca Smith killed eight of her children only because she feared they would grow up to be raging, abusive alcoholics, like their father- so they died from starvation and ruinous neglect, A similar slow death, to arsenic poisoning. Without giving any forgiveness to Mary Anne for her disgraces, she may have suffered from postpartum depression and/or psychosis which often coexisted, especially if she didn’t purposely murder her first daughter. In Modern Medicine, it is commonly believed that postpartum depression stems from the drastic hormonal changes during and after childbirth. Decreased estrogen and progesterone levels place the body into a sudden hormonal shift, and this abrupt change in hormone levels often triggers emotional repercussions, the constant switch from becoming pregnant, losing a child and another and then additionally becoming pregnant again, may cause serious psychological damages. 


As a matter of fact, Arsenic was widely produced in most general stores during this time, used in agriculture as ingredients in insecticides, rat poisons, herbicides and wood preservatives, as well as pigments in paints, wallpaper and ceramics, sometimes even mixed with porcelain, metals and molded to be used as furniture, lamp shades. Many toxic substances we discontinued to use today, were accepted casually in the 19th-century, such as opium, cocaine, lead and even Radium, of course one it was discovered in 1898. Historically speaking, on Halloween of 1858, a mistake was made when two men in a common trading company met. Goddard (a young assistant to a pharmacist) sold 12 pounds (5.4 kg) of arsenic to a sweet shop Candyman, James Appleton. The mistake remained undetected even during manufacture of the sweets by James Appleton, an "experienced sweet maker", though Appleton did observe that the finished product looked different from the usual humbugs (a hard candy with classic white stripes and a coating of sugar). Appleton was suffering symptoms during the sweet-making process and was unwell for several days, with watery vomiting, a headache and pain in his hands and arms. 40 pounds (18 kg) of lozenges were sold to Hardaker who also noticed the sweets looked unusual. This distribution of Candy killed up to 21 people, Approximately, the same victim count to Mary Ann’s crimes. What a coincidence! Mary Ann’s name is often tossed around in these cases, whether she was involved in some way. 


Subsequently, The Husbands were chosen for their Wealth, with Obvious consideration into their financial stability, she wanted but could not get access to because her limits being a Woman in Victorian England. But the selection of the Children she would kill, would be an entirely different rabbit hole. “The Black Widow” was a stereotypical name used to define Women who take off from lover after lover, when they mysteriously die, they usually “kill off” and “take off” usually for the purpose of money, sometimes Sympathy and Attention, oftentimes both. While Mary Ann was still taking nursing inquiries, Parish official-Thomas Riley asked her to help nurse a woman who was dying from Smallpox, but she complained that she wouldn't be able to focus on her nursing duties with her Stepson- 7-year-old Charles Edward Cotton, making noise and causing a disturbance as Children tend to do. This is when Mary Ann led the conversation to her desire to put Charles into the factory warehouse, even suggesting he’s good at counting. Then, Riley suggested that Charles seems unwell, appearing pale and even Lethargic, to which Mary Ann said the infamous- “I won’t be troubled long, He’ll go just like all the rest of the Cottons.” This Comment bothered Riley so much he reported it to the local Police, but not before, only 3 weeks later- the innocent little boy would die from his illness. English Pathologist- William Myers Kibum who once treated the child, kept samples of his urine, which was used by Dr. Thomas Scattergood, lecturer in forensic medicine and Toxicology at the Leeds School of Medicine. Mary was found to have at least bought a 14. oz bottle of Arsenic to use in the Cotton home, disproving her “wallpaper” excuse. 


Finally, Mary Ann was found to be guilty and was hanged March 24th, 1873, publicly. Hangings of Women were rare in the UK. They specifically designed it to be a humiliating and slow process, she apparently struggled for 3 minutes before she went still. The tradition went that the body would stay hanging for an hour before it was taken down. A cast was made of Mary Ann’s lifeless face and was submitted to the Phrenological societies of Hartle pool and Edinburgh. Doubts still stand about whether Mary Ann Cotton was actually even guilty at all. The murders of the 7 people Mary Ann were supposed to have killed have never been investigated at all, outside of just generalized assumptions, the only liable evidence was her track record, and supposed Provocative comment made towards Thomas Riley. As if to demonstrate the legal system Mary Ann was faced with, was not desperate to reform itself, much more can be said to counteract the claim that Mary Ann ever had more than bad luck when it came to the mortality that constantly confronted her. If she killed any at all, how many? There was never any confession coming from Mary Ann., but she did write a series of letters on death row that asserted her innocence, lamented the supposed mistakes she had made, to lead to such accusations, begging friends and relatives to Help her situation. The Trial defence was handled by Thomas Campbell Foster, who argued that Charles had died from inhaling arsenic used as a dye in the green wallpaper of the Cotton home, like she said time and time as the allegations thickened. The same doctor that secured Charles samples- Dr. William Myers Kilbum testified that there was no other powder on the same shelf in the chemist's shop as the arsenic, only liquid; the chemist himself claimed that there were other powders. 


Ultimately, Mary Ann was a detached child, the relationship with parents or guardians is crucial to a basic upbringing. She subsequently became anti-social, unaffected and oblivious to emotions completely. Her mix between grief and anger may have confused the young woman, creating a cocktail of spite and overall very negative perceptions of Human Nature and sense of Morality. Not every pretty mother is who they seem. 













Sources:


  • “Dying for a Humbug, the Bradford Sweets Poisoning 1858.” Historic UK, 22 Sept. 2021,www.historic-uk.com/HistoryUK/HistoryofBritain/Dying-for-Humbug-the-Bradford-Sweets-Poisoning-1858.

    • Devlin, Amanda. “Who Was Mary Ann Cotton and How Many People Did She Kill?...” The Sun, 11 July 2017, www.thesun.co.uk/news/2094755/who-was-mary-ann-cotton-and-how-many-people-did-she-kill.

Monday, October 24, 2022

black swan (2010) video essay script


 Introduction: 

Black Swan is a 2010 drama-psychological film, directed by Darren Aronofsky and written by Mark Heyman, John McLaughlin, and Andres Heinz but predominantly Andres Heinz based on a story he wrote long before the screenplay was produced. The film stars Natalie Portman (as Nina), Vincent Cassel (as Thomas), Mila Kunis (as Lily), Barbara Hershey (As Nina’s mom, Erica), and Winona Ryder (as the original swan queen) the entire layout of the film is about the production of Tchaikovsky's Swan Lake by the New York City Ballet company but really it focuses on Nina, the protagonist and her journey conforming into the Swan Queen, a role she’s wanted all her life. But can she handle this role? Or did she set herself up to fail? Let’s talk about it. Before we get started, this video essay will obviously have spoilers and pretty difficult topics such as bulimia, anorexia, sexual harrasment, rape, self-harm behaviors, sucidal tendancies, schizophrenia hallucinations, panic attacks and suicide. If any of these may be a threat to you, I would suggest you stop watching now. Please make the best choice for yourself. I’ll be breaking this video essay down into 4 sociology concepts that are presented throughout the film, and then making a final conclusion at the end. 

-The Infantilization of Women 

Nina (the protagonist) is purposely presented to the audience to act and seem younger than her real age which is expected to be between 22 to 26 years old, she’s very shy, innocent and easily swayed by her emotions. She lives in a very traditionally girly room with her mother in a small new york city apartment. Because Nina is presented to be a very fragile and vulnerable character, it makes her a target immediately by her peers and by her dancing instructor that eventually casts Nina to be the Swan Queen. She fits the role of the Swan Queen well, but he's not entirely her if she has the courage and ability to be the black swan too. The Concept of female infantilization is a tricky slope to go down, especially considering how normalized it is everyday and everywhere we go. According to https://www.theverdictonline.org/post/the-infantilization-of-women-in-mainstream-media-and-society “A women’s physique in this day and age is steeped in the infantilization of femininity, with one of the seminal examples being that of the adornment of a hairless body. The association of femininity with docility and dependence relays the infantilization of women and the hair removal plays on this conception of women as childish and/or immature. The idea of a hairless body being feminine is inherently infantilizing since it imitates the body of a prepubescent girl and directly ties femininity to physical appearance.” it gets weirder the more you think about it. Let’s talk just about Nina’s relationship with her Mother, Erika. In the perspective of Nina, she seems to be overprotective, precarious and restrictive. Nina doesn't feel comfortable sharing most of her struggles with her mother, because she knows Erika will remind her that the Swan Queen role was always a bad idea. Although Erika makes some poor decisions too, I think she’s actually very misunderstood. According to Interesting Movie Theory: What Is Going on Between Nina and Her Mom In 'Black Swan'? (slashfilm.com) Nina is believed to suffer from paranoid Schizophrenia, hence why she’s still taken care of by her mother as an adult. “Let's assume for the moment that Erica always knew that Nina was a mentally unstable paranoid schizophrenic since the time when Nina was quite young. Sometimes in these situations, where a mother is caring for a mentally ill child the child's life needs to be strictly regimented and controlled in order to maintain stability. This could be the reason why Erica feels the need to restrict Nina's movements and social interactions. It explains why Erica is so protective over Nina as she receives her new, intense role as the white/black swan. It also explains the stuffed animals and other infantilizing elements that are peppered throughout Nina's room and apartment.” 

-Shame in Competition/ The Arch Enemy trope 

The dark side of competition: How competitive behavior and striving to avoid inferiority are linked to depression, anxiety, stress and self-harm | Request PDF (researchgate.net) 

Modern Adult Ballet is without a doubt without fierce competition from Regional to National Level so it’s well known, Nina’s role will play with enormous pressure. In the biggest most famous city of the country. She’s expected to be the best version of a dancer he has ever been in her life. As the climax builds up, the closer we get to the big debut of Swan Lake. It’s more than a production, it's the biggest event in Nina’s life. She’s dedicated too much of herself to a role, we never are really confident she was ready for in the first place. Nina’s mental deterioration is

mainly caused and prolonged from the tight and brutal pressure she’s under. But most of all, she’s afraid of being replaced. She’s constantly consumed in the worry that she’s not good enough. She knows she’s unfit for the demand of the role but she wants it so much, anyone that challenges her, will be her worst nightmare. That’s why Lily is the antagonist, making an accurate depiction of the Arc-Enemy trope in Cinema Arts. Because Nina is not confident in the place she won fairly with her talent she’s willing to do anything it takes to preserve her title. Lily attempts to befriend Nina, whether her intentions are authentic or not is up for debate, but when Nina accepts the request to go out with her to the club, Lily takes advantage of Nina. Nina is in the perfect place to be taken control of because she’s overwhelmed, confused, naive and on the brink of a soon to be psychotic break. Lily waits for Nina to go to the bathroom for her to slip sedatives in Nina’s drink. Nina comes back and watches as she does this, and proceeds to drink the spiked alcohol, and gets taken advantage of all night. Nina is an unreliable narrator because it is shown to us as an audience that she sleeps with Lily and the night ends with a horrible argument with her mother and schizophrenia induced hallucinations that Lily is transformed into a dark and evil version of herself. She wakes up with her mother beside her bed asleep as if she’s been up all night suffering from episodes. 

-Perfection is imperfect 

The biggest moral presented to the audience is the reiteration that perfection is all a girl wants. Though it’s unachievable, it somehow must always be expected. 

Nina herself says “i just want to be perfect’ and fatally, at the end of the film when she drops onto the mattress after a jaw-dropping performance she admits “i was perfect” before ultimately dying. From refusing to eat the celebration cake that her mother buys her and purging to maintain her ballerina weight, we're a witness to her food guilt as well as her bulimic tendencies. Combined with her performance anxiety, stress from living with an overprotective mother, and hints at self-harm, her mental health struggles have a large hand in contributing to Nina's psychosis that she experiences throughout the movie. This movie is basically the rough proof that there is essentially nothing more dangerous than the price of perfection. It gets tragic when the audience realizes that Nina really did dance perfectly, but not without a grueling exposition and horrible downfall of complicated drama. She was groomed, she was abused and she was isolated within herself. One question is raised when Nina hallucinates about killing Lily, when we realize if she didn't really kill Lily, who did she kill? She killed herself. The price of perfection is life itself. According to PsychologyToday- “Perfectionism is driven primarily by internal pressures, such as the desire to avoid failure or harsh judgment. There is likely a social component as well, because perfectionistic tendencies have increased substantially among young people over the past 30 years, regardless of gender or culture. Greater academic and professional competition is thought to play a role, along with the pervasive presence of social media and the harmful social comparisons it elicits.” 

-The “good girl/bad girl” complex 

In a patriarchy or any suppressive societal standard, there exists a black and white concept making it both very hard and very easy to disobey (take that as you will). The Black Swan, specifically, is constructed to portray the effects a patriarchy has on young, vulnerable women already suffering from mental illnesses and other complications. According to bethany webster.com- “A common mask is the mask of the “good girl”. The one who is focused on pleasing others, getting approval, over-functioning in relationships, and performing emotional labor for those in their families. For these little girls, external approval meets survival. Their basic sense of safety is linked to being liked. This ideology sets them up for low self-esteem, poor boundaries and a deep sense of shame. In dysfunctional families, “good girls'' are praised for being invisible, staying quiet and for their willingness to tolerate poor treatment. They are often rejected or abandoned when they say no and their desire for autonomy is shamed.” I couldn't agree more with this article. Nina is a character, yes but there are many Nina’s out there, some of their stories nown and some of their stories unknown.


Tuesday, May 3, 2022

chernobyl} what does an apocolypse look like?

 Exactly, 36 years ago today, as I record this. Chornobyl, Ukraine’s turbine sector, exploded on April 26th, 1986, leaving about 69 people dead on immdeite contact. A low power test went out of control, leading to the explosion and fire that demolished the reactor building and released large amounts of radiation into the atmosphere. Safety measures were ignored, the uranium fuel in the reactor overheated and melted through the protective barriers that shielded the employees from these toxic materials. Initially, that day, the two workers that tested, died from severe burns and immediate blast trauma (don’t look that up) , soon later 28 firemen and rescue workers died only days later from radiation sickness. Experiencing horrific in 2 phases prodrome, latency, manifest illness, and either recovery or death. During the prodromal phase, they usually present with nausea, vomiting, fatigue, and even loss of consciousness at higher doses. The power plant was not equipped to deal with any sort of disaster, they were too focused on success and did not consider any chances of accidents. Traditionally a power plant would have a containment sector, with a gas-tight structure around the nuclear reactor in case anything dangerous occurred. Initially, the Soviet Union tried to hide the real severity of the damage from the rest of the world,  It actually took a week for them to announce globally that the explosion had occurred but still, they failed to warn anyone that radiation had leaked into the large area surrounding Chornobyl. The USSR prevented people from leaving certain locations and cut phone lines to avoid the spread of information. Because of this measure, a lot of the information about this catastrophic event is not known. The other responding officers and reporters died a month later of cancer, usually thyroid cancer, with levels going back to radiation syndrome. But now, we can predict that at least 4,000 people died due to this accident. The safest way to overcome radiation poisoning would be threw a blood transfusion, but now we have evidence that proves nobody received any transfusion, even though Ukraine knew of these treatment possibilities at the time. About 60,000 of the people that inhabited Chornobyl at the time, believed this city would gift them with endless opportunities, like sending their kids to great new schools and making connections in the new world of U.S.S.R technology. It’s really disturbing now, going to Chornobyl to see the devastation and disappointment left behind. 

So much wasted material could've been used to raise intelligent and contributive members of Ukrainian society. The saddest part to me was that the victims that died from radiation exposure had to be buried at Chornobyl to keep the spread down, with steel metal coffins and concrete ceilings. However, far after the explosion, things had to be done to contain the radioactivity. The U.S.S.R dropped 5,000 tons of sand, clay, lead, and boron over the 4th sector and burned the surrounding wildlife. The molten reactor core underneath the reactor was still full of water and if the reactor melted beneath into the water it would cause a third even worse explosion of steam, 3 nuclear plant workers had to go down in that basement, in the dark to turn odd the valves and release the water. They were named the suicide squad because their chances of survival were slim to none, however, to this day all 3 of them survived radiation sickness. Now, we can confirm that Between 50 and 185 million curies of radionuclides escaped into the atmosphere. Millions of acres of forest and farmland were contaminated, livestock was born deformed along with pregnant women’s fetuses, and of course, humans suffered long-term negative health effects. It’s like something out of a horror movie or a creepy sci-fi film. Nobody would ever think this tragedy would happen, they never even saw the need for protective gear back then and contamination protocols. It may all be scary and freaky to the eyes that look in, but to the people that were there, it’s really just devastating. 


One may say, Events like Chornobyl are the reason why we shouldn't trust authority and governmental powers. We depend on them to make big decisions about our economy, healthcare, market, and pretty much every important thing you need to live in an organized society. I’m about to tell you about one individual scientist that held much of the answers to the mystery surrounding Chornobyl’s nuclear explosion. Valery Legasov was a Ukrainian chemist, employed to investigate the causes and mistakes made by the crew working the shift that night on April 26th, 1986. Though the U.S.S.R preferred to keep it known as a simple test gone wrong, Legasov really discovered it was really the outcome of a long history of employee ignorance, gross irresponsibility, neglect of basic protocol, rules and training. The designers that constructed the monitoring lab failed to even build standard safety equipment and protective structures surrounding the labs. People want to believe that the 4th sector was already unstable and dangerous to make sense of the mystery. In Legasov’s investigation, he found Soviet engineer, Vikton Bruykhanvoc, who was a deputy chief engineer for the Chornobyl Nuclear Power Plant. He supervised the safety test which resulted in the disaster. He continued on with the test even after the other chemists on shift that night urged him to shut off the reactors. In court, he argued it was just a simple accident and caused by the “imperfection of technology” even though Bruykhanov was the most trained chemical engineer on staff that night and knew of the reactor’s design flaws and limitations, he had to know somewhere in the back of his head that the reactor 4 was possibly vulnerable to unstable nuclear reactions. With Legasov’s findings presented in court, Bruykhanov was given a maximum sentence of ten years in prison. But still, the Investigation was not over for Legasov and his team. All we do know is that Legasov knew for decades he was uncomfortable operating with reactors in Serbian and Ukrainian chemical plants because there was a significant lack of safety equipment. Emergency training and automation, but like other chemists in the industry at the time, he was almost entirely convinced that nuclear energy could not be dangerous at all and was totally harmless. 

“I, as a chemist was worried about the huge potential of chemical reactions in these devices, there seemed to be too much of graphite, a lot of zirconium and water” -Legasov on trial in 1987 

It would be no secret to learn there was a gross lack of responsibility taken by Brukhanov and he continued to deny his responsibility in court. Legasov recorded his research with an audio recorder and now It’s transcribed and translated for us to read.  He found in files where he stayed at an abandoned psychiatric ward. He stayed there for about 3 weeks while he discovered files after files proving Chornobyl’s hospital system was extremely ill-prepared to deal with a chemical explosion or contamination emergency. They failed to rinse off not even a single patient before treating them, nurses, docters and surgeons lacked proper protective gear and even touched some patients without gloves. Here’s a transcript between Legasov and Ales Adamovich, one of Legasov’s friends that was a Soviet Journilist at the time. Apparently, Adamovich had special ties with Chernobyl’s nuclear plant, he had worked with Alexei Ananenko (who worked sector 4 that day)  and Anatoly Dyatlov, that obviously who we know as responsible for the disaster. This was meant to be a private conversation, but because of the pressure Legasov was under to gather as much information as possible, he secretly recorded this, to listen later for evidence. 

Legasov: But after the 2nd of May, there were traces of a glow a few times in some spots. Either graphite or metal structures were heating up. The last time this was observed was on the 9th or 10th of May. And that’s it. After that, nothing happened.

Adamovich: [Unclear] ...you talk about nitrogen.

Legasov: About nitrogen. There is a lot of confusion in the international press, for example, that Velikhov was measuring something on the roofs around the 26th, Evgeny Pavlovich [Velikhov]. But he was at his dacha, drinking vodka

, and was not aware of anything.

Adamovich: And he was not there on the 26th?

Legasov: He was not there. Yes, he wasn’t.

About nitrogen. This was during Silayev’s time when he has already arrived. It was I who proposed using liquid nitrogen for cooling. This proposal was stupid as practice ha showed. But what was my reasoning? I thought that the reactor shaft was intact. Do you see? And so if we add liquid nitrogen to the air—and we had, very quickly I must say, an entire train of nitrogen brought to us—then that cold air would cool the hot zone better. But then it turned out that the sidewalls of the reactor were wrecked. So all the nitrogen we supplied—and we did find a place for to supplying it—leaked out of the zone and cooled nothing. The natural air circulation was so strong that this nitrogen was like a drop in the ocean. That’s why we quickly discontinued this measure. And in the report I prepared for Vienna, to tell the truth, the Central Committee removed this phrase, but it was in the initial version, that among the ineffective measures was supplying liquid nitrogen.

Now, what else did I want to say about these measures? I repeat that they were invented in continuous phone conversations with Moscow, with experts who assessed, did the thermophysical calculations. For example, dolomite. Anatoly Petrovich Aleksandrov and my student, who called me just now, Silivanov, they thought about which material to use that would generate CO2 and also conduct heat. This is how we chose dolomite which was quickly shipped.

We received many telegrams from abroad, by the way. From these telegrams, I immediately realised that no one [in the world] was prepared for this kind of accident. Because, well, one telegram was just provocative, clearly provocative. It proposed to create another explosion by introducing nitrate mixtures there.

Adamovich: To blow up… 

Unfortunately on April, 27th 1988 the day after the 2nd anniversary of the accident. Valery Legasov was found in his moscow apartment dead, he had apparently hanged himself. He left behind his files where all of this information had been recorded, before It could be seized by the Russian federation, his wife, Margarita Legasova collected these for her own investigation to come about the injust treatment that lead to her husband’s tragic suicide. But why did he commit suicide? Apparently he had been sick for the past 2 years, due to Chernobyl He was in fact very very sick. He was diagnosed with a radiation-induced pancreatic injury, radiation sickness and his bone marrow was damaged. According to his family, he was slowly dying. Legasov became cachectic, almost stopped eating and sleeping. He clearly understood that he was circling the drain. He was under immense pressure form the Soviet labs about this and they would’ve filted most of his findings to keep their name and nuclear work praise. And, this wasn’t his first suicide attempt, previously while in a hospital, he had tried to kill himself by OD’ing sleeping pills. So the reason for his suicide was a combination of several problems. Legasov claimed that Soviet security prevented plant operators from knowing about previous accidents with RMBK reactors and were allowing 16 of the faulty reactors to continue to operate across the Soviet Union in his recordings. He would’ve shown his research work in front of the western world by speaking about what happened in Cherynbol in the Viena Conference but he stated that it was a Human error and also because of poorly design reactors. Vladimir Gubarev, a close friend of Valery Legasov’s who wrote the popular play, Sarcophagus based on Chornobyl, told local publication Pravda that Legasov was ridiculed by his colleagues for his handling of the accident despite receiving international praise for it. He was excluded by a 129-100 vote of his peers from a seat on the scientific and technical council of the Kurchatov Institute of Atomic Energy, where he was once a deputy director. It was a hard blow of rejection for him, and he believed he would get much more praise for his discoveries than he actually did.

Becuase of Chornobyl many safety procedures were put in place at the request of victim’s families. The Law of Belorussian SSR - "On Social Protection of Citizens Affected by the Catastrophe at the Chernobyl NPP" from the 12th of February 1991, the Law of the Ukrainian SSR - "On Status and Social Protection of Citizens Affected by the Accident at the Chernobyl NPP", the Law of Russian Federation. Government decrees have been adopted in Russia regarding social protection of citizens from different regions of the country affected by radionuclides as result of radiation accidents at industrial and military enterprises, or nuclear tests. The existing trend to spread the "Chernobyl law" onto other regions of Russia that have been affected by radiation impacts practically doesnt even consider the peculiarities of radioactive contamination and radiation dose formation to the population. A direct application of the articles of the "Chernobyl law" for these situations is inadmissible. I’d like to make it clear that the Russian government is not to blame here, but they could’ve implemented these laws ages ago, to avoid any catastrophe happening in the first place. Though some citizens are valid to apply for the chernobyl protection program many never get any notice back and have no choice to return to the Exclusion zone to be near family and collect their valuable belongings. Now some changes that have been adopted from this. According to world nuclear.org (sited)  The safety of operating staff is a prime concern in nuclear plants. Radiation exposure is minimised by the use of remote handling equipment for many operations in the core of the reactor. Other controls include physical shielding and limiting the time workers spend in areas with significant radiation levels. Hopefully, this makes working conditions more comfortable for chemical engineers. 

But one question still remains to stand, Is this what a post-apocalyptic world looks like?

 



Credits:

https://www.iaea.org/newscenter/focus/chernobyl/faqs#:~:text=1.,of%20radiation%20into%20the%20atmosphere.

https://www.livescience.com/chernobyl-exclusion-zone

https://www.britannica.com/event/Chernobyl-disaster

https://euobserver.com/world/21409\

https://www.oecd-nea.org/jcms/pl_14152/international-nuclear-law-in-the-post-chernobyl-period?details=true

https://www.gao.gov/blog/2019/09/12/how-chernobyl-jump-started-the-global-nuclear-safety-regime

http://www.rri.kyoto-u.ac.jp/NSRG/reports/kr21/kr21pdf/Zgersky.pdf